S&W 686 vs Ruger GP100: The Biggest Lie in the Revolver World
Watch on YouTube More from Gun Hun →
On October 13, 2026 Ruger suspended production of the GP100 — the revolver that for 40 years was the other half of the biggest argument in the revolver world. So which should you buy now: the Smith & Wesson 686 or the Ruger GP100? "The Ruger is the tank, the Smith is the fine watch" is what every gun counter says. That's the biggest lie in the revolver world. Here are the five comparisons that actually decide it — history, strength, trigger, size and carry, price and value — and the one question that tells you which side of the line you're on.
Chapters
Chapters
- 0:00 Ruger pauses the GP100
- 1:26 The .357 Magnum: why this argument exists
- 3:45 1. History
- 6:54 2. Strength
- 9:49 3. The trigger
- 11:34 4. Size, carry and recoil
- 13:48 5. Price and value
- 16:09 The line that decides everything
- 16:48 If you can't find either one
- 17:31 The honest part: what to check before you buy
- 19:00 Which one do you own?
Ruger describes the GP100 suspension as a pause, not necessarily a permanent discontinuation (American Rifleman, Oct. 14, 2026). Prices come from retail listings and change. Some states keep handgun rosters. Check your state and local laws and buy through a licensed dealer. None of this is a recommendation.
Footage and photo credits
Footage used under Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) — thank you:
TheFirearmGuy: https://youtu.be/XfGyary8RkY
SchizoSaint: https://youtu.be/zZm8MasKsMs https://youtu.be/qnjHLQ6ckFQ
Counterstrike 1911: https://youtu.be/abXQr1E1-Y4 https://youtu.be/J5AbGYAGFVY
Firearm Reviews: https://youtu.be/IyASORnwBUI
//// : https://youtu.be/ion02_p_AiE
Armas y Militaria: https://youtu.be/6yG3w6hXvpI
DanTheWolfman: https://youtu.be/KSbPBxQ1OqM
gunsofnorway: https://youtu.be/7rG1TAVqlBM https://youtu.be/9JWiummNwpA
waffensachverstand com: https://youtu.be/wGbruRl-_iw
Gilly T: https://youtu.be/l_xKt2Nn1vI